gns3-server/docs/features/docker-kernel-datapath.md
YueGuobin 86651604c4
test(e2e): relay capture and markers on both relay engines
The relay engines' observable paths had no live coverage: every
capture/start call in the suite sat on a kernel anchor (AF_PACKET
capture start_kernel) and markers were only asserted on marker
add_kernel. The two relay engines' own command shapes were unit-tested
only:
  * bridge engine  - bridge start_capture / bridge add_packet_filter ... mark
  * iol_bridge engine - iol_bridge start_capture / iol_bridge add_packet_filter ... mark

Docker relay control (bridge engine, 1 passed 33s): the capture start
REST call writes the ICMP exchange to a pcap off the relay bridge; a
mark filter attached with capture_node_id n1 signals exactly 10
marker.match events over the dedicated marker WS for 5 pings (5
requests + 5 replies, both directions), carrying node_id/link_id/tag and
the busybox frame length, writes exactly those 10 frames to the marker
pcap, and deleting the marker takes the pcap with it.

IOU relay control (iol_bridge engine, 1 passed 173s): the same two
checks on iol_bridge start_capture and the port's mark filter, driven
by the real IOS ping through the fabric socket relay.

Not duplicated in the ESW/VPCS/cloud relay controls: they issue the same
uBridge bridge commands through their own call sites, which stay covered
by unit tests; the IOL container relay goes through the same iol_bridge
engine already exercised here.
2026-10-06 00:21:10 +08:00

491 lines
31 KiB
Markdown
Raw Blame History

This file contains ambiguous Unicode characters

This file contains Unicode characters that might be confused with other characters. If you think that this is intentional, you can safely ignore this warning. Use the Escape button to reveal them.

<!--
SPDX-License-Identifier: CC-BY-SA-4.0
See LICENSE file for licensing information.
-->
> This documentation is AI-generated with reference to actual code and verified
> against real-kernel testing. AI can make mistakes — please verify against
> the source code when in doubt.
# Docker Kernel Datapath (veth + per-link Linux bridge)
## Overview
Docker node links historically flowed through a uBridge userspace relay: each
adapter was a TAP whose file descriptor uBridge pumped between the container
and UDP tunnels. This implementation replaces that model with **kernel-native
forwarding**: every adapter is born as a **veth pair**, and each link is a
**dedicated Linux kernel bridge** enslaving the two endpoints' veth host ends.
Frames never leave the kernel.
| | Old (relay) | New (kernel datapath) |
|---|---|---|
| Adapter interface | TAP moved into the container netns | veth pair (guest end in container, host end in root ns) |
| Link | uBridge bridge, TAP fd ↔ UDP, userspace copy | per-link kernel bridge `gns3{link_id[:11]}`, zero-copy |
| Relay latency | ~0.3 ms RTT | ~0.05 ms RTT (measured) |
| Link attach at runtime | yes (relay attaches the pre-existing TAP) | yes (brctl addif / add_nio_ethernet — interface untouched) |
| Packet filters | uBridge userspace filters | tc netem on the veth host end (delay / packet_loss / corrupt / duplicate + the netem extensions rate, reorder, gemodel, seed, limit, jitter distributions, loss correlation); bpf as cls_bpf match-drop classifiers; frequency_drop, quota and window_drop as the eBPF stateful classifier — every filter type has a kernel equivalent |
| Capture / markers | relay bridge | uBridge AF_PACKET modules on the veth host end |
The work landed in nine stages on branch stack `feat/docker-kernel-datapath` →
`feat/docker-kernel-capture` → `feat/docker-kernel-markers` →
`feat/docker-veth-everywhere` → `feat/docker-kernel-filters` →
`feat/docker-kernel-bpf-drop` → `feat/docker-kernel-netem-ext` →
`feat/docker-kernel-ebpf-drops` → `feat/docker-kernel-window-drop`:
1. **Kernel datapath** — NIOBridge NIO type, per-link bridges, carrier-based
suspend, crash-safe reconciliation.
2. **Capture** — `capture start_kernel` (AF_PACKET) on the veth host end.
3. **Markers** — `marker add_kernel` (AF_PACKET + BPF) with the same signals,
pcaps and fine-grained REST operations as the relay `mark` filter.
4. **veth-everywhere** — the TAP path deleted; every adapter is a veth and the
datapath is a *runtime* decision (kernel or relay) that never touches a
running container's interfaces.
5. **Filters** — impairment filters (delay, packet_loss, corrupt) become one
tc netem qdisc per veth host end, pushed through uBridge's netlink `tc`
module. This also removes the relay delay filter's nanosleep bottleneck
(upstream #2827) from the kernel path.
6. **bpf match-drop** — the `bpf` filter (any line matching drops) runs as
cls_bpf classifiers on the veth host end's clsact egress (`tc bpf_drop`:
uBridge pcap-compiles the line to classic BPF, the kernel migrates it to
eBPF internally — no CAP_BPF needed). Requires a uBridge reporting
`cbpf=1` via `tc capabilities`; older builds get a clear upgrade error.
7. **netem extensions** — the netem-extension surface delivered in uBridge
`feature/tc-netem-ext` is exposed as GNS3 filter types: `rate`,
`reorder`, `gemodel`, `duplicate`, `seed`, `limit`, plus the delay
`distribution` and loss/dup `correlation` parameters. Kernel-datapath
links only (the relay has no equivalent); capability-gated per uBridge
process. Reconcile became reset-before-set: the kernel's netem replace
merges optional attributes, so removing a parameter needs the explicit
reset.
8. **eBPF stateful drops** — `frequency_drop` becomes the eBPF classifier's
exact every-Nth mode (`tc nth_drop`, uBridge `feature/tc-precision`;
-1 = drop everything → every 1st) and the new kernel-only `quota` type
the byte-cap mode (`tc quota_drop`). Needs a uBridge reporting `ebpf=1`
(setcap cap_bpf,cap_net_admin,cap_net_raw=ep — verified working for a
non-root server process, the production credential shape). With this,
no filter type forces the relay anymore: kernel/relay is a purely
topological choice.
9. **window_drop flaps** — the eBPF classifier's time-window mode
(`tc window_drop`, uBridge `feature/tc-window`): a single outage that
passes traffic before and after, a recurring flap with `period ≥ outage`,
and an optional per-cycle jitter that randomizes each beat's outage and
period. The originally delivered back-to-back window implementation
(which made "outside the window packets pass" unreachable) was fixed
uBridge-side; this stage exposes the corrected semantics as the
kernel-only `window_drop` filter type.
## Adapter interface types
Which interface a Docker node's adapters use is decided by the node class
(`Docker._select_node_class`, from `console_type` + `GNS3_*` environment
markers):
| Node class | Selected by | Adapter interface | Kernel links |
|---|---|---|---|
| `DockerVM` | default | veth pair | yes |
| `VendorDockerVM` (non-unix-socket) | `console_type=docker_exec`, `GNS3_SKIP_INIT`, … (XRd, SR Linux, …) | veth pair (same path via `super()`) | yes |
| `IOLDockerVM` | `GNS3_IOL_RUNNER=1` | AF_UNIX datagram socket pairs (`sNN`/`cNN`) — the container netns is unused; kernel links ride persistent `gx` TAP anchors through the port bridge's swappable TAP leg (see `iol-docker-kernel-datapath.md`) | yes (gated on `ubridge_bridge_tap` + `ubridge_tap`) |
| `VendorDockerVM` (unix-socket) | `GNS3_UNIX_SOCKET_NIO=1` | same socket contract, generic capability for vendor NOS images | rejected |
Unix-socket containers are detected both in the controller
(`_is_unix_socket_docker`, link eligibility) and on the compute side (NIO
rejection) — a missed detection surfaces as a clearer-late error.
## Architecture
Kernel link between two containers on the same compute:
```
container A netns root namespace container B netns
┌────────────┐ veth pair ┌───────────────────┐ veth pair ┌────────────┐
│ eth0 ◄─────┼───────────────┼─► gv{id}e0p0 ──────┼──► gns3{lid} │──────────► │ eth0
└────────────┘ gc{id}e0p0 │ (bridge port) │ (bridge port)│ └────────────┘
│ per-link kernel │ gv{id}e0p0
│ bridge = "cable" │
└───────────────────┘
```
Relay link on the same unified veth (fallback for mixed node types, cross-
compute wiring or when `enable_kernel_datapath` is off):
```
┌────────────┐ ┌────────────────────────────┐ ┌────────────┐
│ eth0 │ veth │ uBridge relay bridge │ UDP │ peer node │
│ (gc end) │◄────────────►│ add_nio_ethernet (AF_ │◄────────────►│ (any type, │
└────────────┘ gv host end │ PACKET) ↔ add_nio_udp │ tunnel │ any host) │
└────────────────────────────┘ └────────────┘
```
Both datapaths anchor on the *same* veth host end; switching between them
(link delete + recreate) never touches the container-side interface.
## Datapath selection
`UDPLink._kernel_datapath_eligible` decides in the controller at NIO prepare
time; the compute side only reacts to the NIO type:
* both endpoints Docker (any class except unix-socket containers), same
compute
* `Server.enable_kernel_datapath` enabled (default)
Filters never disqualify the kernel path anymore — every type has a kernel
equivalent (netem / cls_bpf / eBPF classifier).
There is **no stopped-node requirement**. Since every adapter is a veth, links
attach to running containers: `brctl addif` (kernel) or
`bridge add_nio_ethernet` (relay) are runtime-safe operations on the host end.
On project (re)open every link re-runs `_prepare`, so relay links whose
endpoints became eligible are upgraded to the kernel datapath automatically.
Which datapath a link ended up on is visible in its REST payload (and the
`link_list` / `link_get` MCP tools) as the read-only boolean
`kernel_datapath`, recomputed from the NIO wiring — a relay link upgraded on
reopen flips the field. It is not persisted and never sent on create/update.
## Adapter lifecycle
* **Birth (container start)** — `_create_veth`: stale sweep of any leftover
pair (crash residue), `docker create_veth`, host end admin-down, MAC from
the adapter base, `docker move_to_ns` of the guest end (renamed `eth{N}`, or
the `GNS3_INTERFACE_NAMES` mapping). Names are deterministic:
`gv|gc{node_id[:8]}e{adapter}p{port}` (≤ 15 chars). Unconnected adapters are
born too (carrier off) so the interface is visible inside the container.
* **Life (running)** — the veth is never created/deleted/moved again. Link
create/delete/switch, suspend, capture and markers only change *what is
attached to the host end*.
* **Death (container stop)** — `_remove_kernel_veths` deletes the host ends
explicitly: unlike a TAP (which died with the container netns), a veth host
end outlives the container. Deleting either end destroys the pair. The
node's per-link kernel bridges go with them — deleting a node or closing a
project never runs the link-teardown path (no per-link delete is issued),
so a bridge whose ports just disappeared would stay behind as an empty
orphan. Both endpoints do this and the peer's still-enslaved port makes
the delete fail with EBUSY (suppressed, last one wins), the same contract
as link deletion; a node restart rebuilds the bridge from the NIO.
* **Host L3 noise (known, hardening specified).** An anchor is a host-side
netdev like any other, so the kernel gives it an IPv6 link-local address and
emits its own MLD/DAD from it (measured ≈6 frames / 2 s on an idle TAP; the
production anchors and per-link bridges carry `fe80::…` today). On a kernel
link the bridge floods those frames into the emulated segment — and the host
answers neighbor solicitations for its own address, which looks like a phantom
IPv6 neighbor to the emulated nodes. The fix is to make anchors pure L2 at
creation time on the uBridge side:
`docs/design/ubridge-l2-anchor-spec.md`.
## Link operations
| Operation | Kernel-datapath action |
|---|---|
| Create / attach | `brctl create` (EEXIST tolerated via `brctl show` verify) + `link set up` + `brctl addif` both ends (concurrent, race-tolerant) + carrier up + markers + `tc netem set` (filters) |
| Delete / detach | marker teardown → `tc reset` (netem teardown — the veth survives the link) → carrier off → `brctl delif` → `brctl delete` (last endpoint wins; EBUSY/ENOENT suppressed). The veth survives — unlike a relay bridge, whose death dropped its filters, an orphaned AF_PACKET marker would keep sniffing, hence the explicit teardown |
| Reset (`POST /links/{id}/reset`) | delete + create (re-evaluates eligibility) |
| Suspend (`PUT /links/{id}` `{"suspend": true}`) | veth host end admin-state down both ends — 100 % loss, no synthetic filter needed; resume restores (netem qdisc survives the carrier flap) |
## Capture
Kernel links capture via uBridge's AF_PACKET module bound to the veth host
end: `capture start_kernel <if> "<pcap>" [dlt]` / `capture stop_kernel`.
Single capture per uBridge process (second concurrent → EALREADY). Start/stop
key on the **NIO type**, not on veth presence — a relay NIO riding a veth
captures at its relay bridge.
## Markers
Markers ride the NIO like on the relay datapath, routed by `capture_node_id`;
the anchor is the veth host end instead of a relay bridge
(`_ubridge_apply_markers(anchor, nio)` is datapath-agnostic; DockerVM
overrides the add/delete/enable primitives to translate the commands):
```
marker add_kernel <name> <if> "<bpf>" [tag <id>] [link <id>] [dir <tx|rx>] [linktype <name>] [pcap "<path>"]
marker delete_kernel <if> <name> # idempotent
marker enable_kernel <if> <name> <on|off> # off = installed but silent
```
* Per-deployment convention: **only the capture node's end** runs
`add_kernel` (symmetric with capture) — signals form clean send/return
pairs (`PACKET_OUTGOING` on the host end = container receiving = `rx`).
* Same BPF compilation, MARK UDP signals, pcap files and fine-grained REST
toggle/rebuild/delete endpoints as the relay `mark` filter.
* Node restart reinstalls markers from the NIO; link deletion tears them down.
## Packet filters
Impairment filters run **in the kernel** as tc netem qdiscs on the veth host
ends (uBridge `tc netem set`, raw netlink — no `tc` binary needed):
| GNS3 filter | kernel implementation | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| `delay [ms, jitter, dist]` | netem `delay X jitter Y [distribution D]` | jitter 0 omitted; dist ∈ uniform/normal/pareto/paretonormal (kernel-only parameter) |
| `packet_loss [%, correl]` | netem `loss P [correl C]` | per direction (see below); correlation is a kernel-only parameter |
| `corrupt [%]` | netem `corrupt P` | |
| `duplicate [%, correl]` | netem `dup P [correl C]` | kernel-only type |
| `rate ["512kbit"]` | netem `rate B` | tc-style integer+unit (bit/kbit/mbit/gbit/bps/kbps/mbps, ≤100gbit); kernel-only type |
| `reorder [%, correl, gap]` | netem `reorder P [correl C] [gap G]` | requires `delay`; kernel-only type |
| `gemodel [p, r, 1-h]` | netem `loss gemodel P R H` | Gilbert-Elliot bursty loss: p = good→bad transition, r = bad→good transition, 1-h = loss chance in the bad state (good loses nothing) — mean one-way loss p/(p+r)×(1-h); mutually exclusive with `packet_loss`; kernel-only type |
| `seed [u32]` | netem `seed N` | reproducible random draws; kernel-only type |
| `limit [pkts]` | netem `limit N` | queue depth above the 1000 default (rate+delay BDP); kernel-only type |
| `bpf` (one line per expression, OR) | `tc bpf_drop add <if> <prio> "<expr>"` — cls_bpf on clsact egress + gact drop | needs uBridge `cbpf=1` (`tc capabilities`, probed once per uBridge process); a line that fails to compile on the compute is skipped with a warning, mirroring the relay |
| `frequency_drop [N]` | `tc nth_drop <if> N` — the eBPF stateful classifier's exact every-Nth mode (clsact egress prio 1) | needs uBridge `ebpf=1`; -1 = drop everything → every 1st; per-direction counters (see below) |
| `quota [bytes, %]` | `tc quota_drop <if> <bytes> <pct>` — after the byte quota is consumed, each further packet drops with the given chance (100 = hard cutoff) | kernel-only type; needs `ebpf=1`; per-direction byte counters |
| `window_drop [start, outage, %, period?, jitter?]` | `tc window_drop <if> <start> <outage> <pct> [<period> [<jitter>]]` — packets drop with the given chance inside `[start, start+outage)` | kernel-only type; needs `ebpf=1`; see the window semantics below |
Semantics:
* **Both endpoints** receive the filter dict and attach one qdisc to *their*
veth host end. The qdisc's egress covers traffic entering that container,
so every direction of the link is impaired exactly once — the same net
effect as the relay, where both directions cross the single filtered
bridge. A `delay 100` link measures ≈200 ms RTT; `packet_loss 30`
measures ≈51 % round-trip (1 − 0.7²); `rate 512kbit` adds ≈2× the
per-packet serialization time to the RTT.
* **Reconcile = reset + full re-apply.** The kernel's netem replace MERGES
optional attributes (rate, correlation, reorder, corrupt, gemodel,
distribution: an absent attr keeps its previous value), so re-applying a
filter set with a parameter *removed* would silently keep the old value.
Every apply therefore starts with `tc reset` (also drops clsact and its
bpf_drop filters — re-added right after in the same flow) followed by one
`netem set` built from the current filters; no per-parameter diffing. An
empty filter set is the reset alone (ENOENT-tolerated).
* **Extension gating.** The netem-extension keywords (rate, reorder,
gemodel, dist, seed, limit, and the correl suffixes) probe
`tc capabilities` once per uBridge process and require the tokens;
a plain delay/loss/corrupt/dup filter never probes — an old uBridge
serves the original surface untouched.
* **kernel-only vs relay-available.** The extension types and `quota` have
no uBridge relay equivalent: `available_filters` hides them on relay
links, setting one on a created relay link returns 409, and a project
loaded with such filters on a link that cannot be kernel-wired drops them
with a warning (invalid filters are dropped the same way at load).
`frequency_drop` runs on both datapaths (relay userspace filter / eBPF
every-Nth).
* **frequency_drop counting semantics differ per datapath.** The relay's
single filtered bridge counts packets of BOTH directions through one
counter; the kernel attaches one classifier per veth end, so each
direction drops every Nth independently. For a round-trip measurement
with every-Nth N: relay ≈ 1/N of frames (phase-locked), kernel = 1 −
((N−1)/N)² (e.g. N=3 → 55.6 % round-trip loss, measured 57 %). The
kernel count is exact (atomic counter), unlike netem's stochastic loss.
* **Classifier order** on clsact egress: the eBPF stateful filter runs at
prio 1, `bpf_drop` expressions at 10–99 — a packet dropped by the
stateful modes never reaches the expression drops, and dropped packets
never reach netem. Within the stateful program the modes evaluate in the
fixed order nth → quota → window.
* **window_drop semantics.** `start` is relative to the moment the filter
is applied — and because reconcile re-sets the classifier on every apply
(any filter change, node restart, link reset reloads the program after
the netem reset), every such event **restarts the schedule**. 3
parameters = one single outage (`[start, start+outage)`), traffic passes
before and after — the classic "link dies at T, comes back at T+outage".
4 parameters = recurring flap: `period ≥ outage` (validated), so the
outage occupies `outage/period` of each cycle. 5 parameters = randomized
flap: each cycle's outage and period are re-drawn uniformly in nominal
± `jitter` (integer-ms grid; jitter 0 draws nothing and equals the fixed
schedule). Inside a window each packet drops with the given chance (100
= full outage, lower = degraded service during the window). Both
endpoints run their own schedule, started ~simultaneously by the
controller — a round trip survives only when **both** directions are
outside their windows. Note `start = 0` (outage begins immediately) is a
valid, active configuration — unlike other filters, a zero first
parameter does not mean "disabled". A PUT re-sending an unchanged filters
dict is normally a controller no-op, but one still carrying `window_drop`
is reconciled anyway, so re-applying the same window re-arms a one-shot
outage that has already passed (arm the filter immediately before
generating traffic, or use a period for a repeatable event).
* **Validation** mirrors the tc grammar: `reorder` requires `delay`,
`gemodel` and `packet_loss` are mutually exclusive (both map to the netem
loss keyword), `distribution` requires jitter > 0, rate must be integer +
unit ≤ 100gbit.
* **Node restart** restores the qdisc from the NIO (like capture and markers);
**link deletion** detaches it explicitly — the veth survives the link and an
orphaned qdisc would keep impairing the next one.
* **Suspend** keeps the qdisc (carrier-driven loss); the first packet after
resume takes one extra delay interval (known netem idle-baseline behaviour)
and steady state is exact.
* **bpf reconcile = flush + re-add** (`tc bpf_drop flush`, then one add per
line at priorities 10, 11, …). `tc reset` (link delete / filter clear) is
the full restore in uBridge: filters → clsact → root qdisc, idempotent.
* **Observability caveat:** clsact drops happen before the AF_PACKET tap
points — markers/captures on the same veth do not observe cls_bpf-dropped
frames (on the relay, filter-vs-mark ordering determined visibility
instead). Also note `tc qdisc show` cannot print a distribution's name
(the kernel stores only the sampled table).
* **eBPF mode tokens.** A stateful mode is usable iff `tc capabilities`
reports `ebpf=1` **and** lists the mode's token in `ebpf_modes`
(uBridge `feature/tc-window`+). Builds predating the field keep the modes
that shipped with it — everything but `window`, whose semantics were
corrected exactly when the field was added: gating on `ebpf=1` alone
would silently install the broken back-to-back-window behaviour on a
pre-correction build. Requesting an unusable mode fails the apply with an
upgrade error; the cleanup ("off") path only touches modes the build
declares.
* **Capability reporting.** The compute exposes the probe through
`GET /v3/compute/capabilities` as `ubridge_tc` (netem keyword list,
`ebpf`/`cbpf` flags, and the usable `ebpf_modes` — legacy fallback
applied), answered by a throwaway uBridge spawned as the server's own
user and cached by binary identity — the runtime `ebpf` flag flips
between users and kernels for the same binary, so a root-run probe would
lie for a non-root server. The controller forwards it through
`GET /v3/computes` and `available_filters` hides kernel-datapath filter
types an endpoint compute reports it cannot run (both ends apply their
own filters, so one incapable compute is enough). Computes that report
nothing — older servers, failed probe — keep the full list;
apply-time validation (409) stays the guard.
## uBridge command surface
No uBridge changes were needed beyond the marker module's `*_kernel` commands
(the AF_PACKET capture module was pre-existing):
```
docker create_veth / delete_veth / move_to_ns / set_mac_addr
brctl create / delete / addif / delif / show
link set <if> up|down
capture start_kernel / stop_kernel
marker add_kernel / delete_kernel / enable_kernel
tc netem set <if> [delay <ms>] [jitter <ms>] [loss <%> [correl <%>] | loss gemodel <p> <r> <1-h>]
[dup <%> [correl <%>]] [corrupt <%>] [reorder <%> [correl <%>] [gap <n>]]
[rate <bw>] [limit <pkts>] [distribution uniform|normal|pareto|paretonormal] [seed <u32>]
tc bpf_drop add <if> <prio 10-99> "<expr>" / tc bpf_drop flush <if>
tc nth_drop <if> <n | off> # eBPF exact every-Nth (frequency_drop)
tc quota_drop <if> <bytes> <pct> | off # eBPF byte cap (quota)
tc window_drop <if> <start_ms> <outage_ms> <pct> [<period_ms> [<jitter_ms>]] | off # eBPF time window (window_drop)
tc reset <if> # full restore: eBPF filter -> bpf_drops -> clsact -> root qdisc, idempotent
tc capabilities # "netem=<kw,...>;ebpf=0|1;cbpf=0|1[;ebpf_modes=<modes>]", probed once per process
bridge add_nio_ethernet / add_nio_udp / start / stop / start_capture / stop_capture
```
## Configuration
```ini
[Server]
# Wire eligible Docker-to-Docker links through kernel veth/bridge interfaces
enable_kernel_datapath = True
```
Intended to grow into the global datapath switch as IOU / Dynamips migrate to
kernel bridges. **QEMU has landed** on the same pattern (persistent TAP anchor
enslaved into the per-link bridge, zero relay) — see
`docs/features/qemu-kernel-datapath.md` — and **IOU after it**
(`docs/features/iou-kernel-datapath.md`; the fabric terminator in uBridge
gained a TAP-terminated port, `iol_bridge add_nio_tap`, specified in
`docs/design/ubridge-iol-tap-anchor-spec.md`). The shared half of this
document's compute machinery now lives in
`gns3server/compute/kernel_datapath.py`.
## Verification
End-to-end on a five-container FRR topology (mixed runtime-drawn and reloaded
links): 8/8 links on the kernel datapath, ping RTT ≈ 0.05 ms, FDB learning,
suspend = 100 % loss / resume restores, project reopen upgrades relay links,
runtime link creation on running containers, marker pcaps exact (tx/rx
pairs), capture freeze on stop, server restart reconciliation.
Filters (two-container kernel link, 27/27 checks): baseline 0.06 ms →
`delay 100` = 200.2 ms RTT (2× per direction) → `delay 50` = 100.2 ms
(atomic replace) → clear = baseline (qdisc detached); `packet_loss 30` =
48 % round-trip loss (expected 51 % = 1 − 0.7²); `frequency_drop` = 409 (at that
stage — superseded by the eBPF stage below);
suspend with delay active = 100 % loss, resume keeps the qdisc
(200.1 ms); node restart restores it (200.1 ms); link delete detaches it
(`/usr/sbin/tc qdisc show` — no netem left); re-created link has no residual
impairment.
bpf match-drop (same setup, 22/22 checks): `bpf "icmp"` = 100 % loss on both
ends' clsact; size-discriminating expression (`greater 150`) = small pings
pass / 300-byte pings dropped (real byte-level BPF match); two-line OR;
coexistence with netem (delay 50 → small pings 100.2 ms while big dropped);
clear removes clsact entirely; suspend/resume keeps the drops; link delete +
recreate leaves no residual filters; `frequency_drop` still 409 and hidden
(at that stage — superseded by the eBPF stage below); `available_filters` shows
`bpf`. Unit tests:
`tests/compute/docker/test_docker_kernel_datapath.py`,
`tests/controller/test_kernel_datapath_link.py`.
netem extensions (same setup, 24/24 checks): `rate 512kbit` on both veths,
1400-byte pings measure 45.5 ms RTT = baseline + 2× the 22.2 ms
serialization (exact); `delay 100 20 paretonormal` applies delay+jitter and
clears the previous rate (leak detector for the kernel's merge-on-replace);
`reorder 25 gap 5` visible in the qdisc dump and traffic passes;
`gemodel 100/0/30` = 50 % bursty round-trip loss with the previous reorder
cleared; `duplicate 50` link alive; `packet_loss 30 correl 50` shows
`loss 30% 50%`; `seed 42` + `limit 5000` both visible in the dump, RTT
exactly 2×50 ms; suspend/resume and node restart keep the filters; a
docker↔ethernet-switch relay link rejects `rate` with 409 and its
`available_filters` hides the kernel-only types while the kernel link shows
them all (frequency_drop included since the eBPF stage); `reorder` without `delay` and
`gemodel`+`packet_loss` are 409s; teardown leaves no netem on either veth.
Also verified live: a relay attach (`bridge add_nio_ethernet`) on the
admin-down veth host end fails in libpcap — the relay path now brings the
interface up before attaching.
eBPF stateful drops (same setup, 13/13 checks): `frequency_drop 3` installs
the tc_impair classifier on both veths (clsact egress pref 1, visible in
`tc filter show`); round-trip loss 57 % against the per-direction theory 1 −
(2/3)² = 55.6 % (each direction drops every 3rd independently — the relay's
single shared counter would give ≈ 1/3); `frequency_drop -1` = exactly
100 % loss; `quota 3000B/100 %` = pings pass until the byte cap then hard
cutoff; coexistence with `delay 50` (RTT 100.3 ms with every-4th drops);
clearing filters leaves no residual bpf filter; suspend = 100 % while down
with drops persisting after resume; node restart restores every-Nth on the
fresh veth; `available_filters` shows frequency_drop + quota on kernel
links and hides quota on relay links; a two-leg relay path through an
Ethernet switch still serves frequency_drop from the userspace filter
(56 % round-trip for N=3). The e2e also exposed and fixed a pre-existing
restart bug: the relay bridge-name registry was not cleared on stop, so a
node restart with a relay link skipped `bridge create` and failed. Unit tests:
`tests/utils/test_packet_filter_validation.py` (P6a class),
`tests/compute/docker/test_docker_kernel_datapath.py`,
`tests/controller/test_kernel_datapath_link.py`.
window_drop (same setup, 15/15 checks, against uBridge `feature/tc-window`):
a single outage `[1000, 1500, 100]` delivers **per-seq evidence** of the B.2
semantics — one ping per 200 ms arrives as `[0,1,2,3,4, 13…19]`: passing
before the window, dropped inside it, passing again after; a recurring flap
`[300, 1000, 100, 2000]` measures 52 % round-trip loss (the 1000/2000 duty
cycle); `period == outage` is a permanent outage (100 %); `period < outage`
is a 409 before uBridge sees it; a jittered flap
`[0, 1000, 100, 2000, 400]` keeps the ~50 % duty cycle (62 % sampled over
4 cycles — the per-cycle re-draw widens the variance by design); a 30 %
chance on a permanent window measures 53 % round trip against the
per-direction theory 1 − 0.7² = 51 % (the same arithmetic as
`packet_loss 30`); `start = 0` is stored as an *active* filter; the window
coexists with netem (`delay 50` + a permanent window = 100 % inside the
outage); clearing removes the classifier; a node restart restores the
schedule on the fresh veth; `available_filters` shows window_drop on kernel
links and a relay link both hides it and 409s it; teardown leaves no filter
or qdisc behind. The P6b e2e was re-run as a regression on the same uBridge
build (13/13 — nth/quota unaffected by the de-looping below).
In-repo live coverage: `tests/e2e/test_docker_kernel_datapath.py` (pytest
marker `e2e`) runs two real Alpine containers on an isolated instance — the
per-link bridge enslaving exactly the two veth host ends, real ICMP, the
L2-anchor spec §E assertions (no L3 identity, forwarding ports, idle
silence with the guests' links down), the filter matrix one type at a time
(netem core and extensions, cls_bpf match-drop, the eBPF classifier, each
asserted through real traffic), suspend, capture, link delete/re-create,
container stop/start, a relay negative control — whose own filters
(delay/frequency_drop/bpf) really shape the relay wire, whose capture and
markers ride the same relay engine (`bridge start_capture`, the bridge
`mark` filter) — and the relay→kernel upgrade on project reopen (the
datapath choice is flipped across a server restart). The container image is digest-pinned and pulled through the
server's own pull route on a cache miss, so collaborators test the same
bytes.
The uBridge-side window work took two fixes that are worth recording, both
found by *this* integration rather than by unit tests: the delivered
catch-up loop tripped the verifier's 8192 **jump-sequence** budget — on the
non-root path the verifier drops the loop counter's bound
(`R4=scalar(smax=umax32=0xfffff086)`), treats the loop as unbounded and
unrolls it until the pending-state limit, so the program was rejected
wholesale (`E2BIG`, `The sequence of 8193 jumps is too complex`) and
`tc capabilities` reported `ebpf=0` — taking `frequency_drop` and `quota`
down with it, since the classifier loads as one program; lowering the trip
cap did not help (128 trips failed identically), removing the loop did
(572ca0c: 16-step unroll + outer guard, zero back edges). A latent Makefile
header-dependency gap (53e34bb) had been shipping the *old* truncated
program object — the kernel answered `jump out of range from insn 9 to
421` with `processed 0 insns`. Both matter to anyone rebuilding uBridge:
`ebpf=1` from a direct probe is the only trustworthy signal.